Skip to content

How to Choose a Shopify Plus Agency in 2026: Costs, Red Flags, Questions to Ask

Choose a Shopify Plus agency on Plus work you can check, a line-by-line price, a named developer and written support terms. Real prices by project type, what partner tiers mean before and after 2027, 10 questions, red flags and a scoring checklist.

How to Choose a Shopify Plus Agency in 2026: Costs, Red Flags, Questions to Ask

Choose a Shopify Plus agency on four things: live Plus work like yours that you can open and check, a written price for each part of the scope, a named senior developer who will do the build, and support terms in the contract. Partner tier shows scale, not quality, and Shopify’s directory no longer shows reviews, so call references yourself.

Everything below about Shopify’s partner program, checkout and redirects was checked on Shopify’s own pages on 18 November 2026. The prices are our own published prices, because they are the only agency prices we can vouch for.

What does a Shopify Plus agency cost?

Most agencies don’t publish prices, and the ranges you find online are mostly agencies’ own estimates with no source. Ours are public: a store build starts at €3,000, a migration at €5,000, and Shopify Plus builds are quoted per project because integrations and B2B rules change the scope the most.

Project typeOur priceWhat moves the price
Shopify store buildfrom €3,000Number of page templates, apps to set up, content to load
Custom theme built from your designfrom €8,000Number of templates and custom sections
Custom design and custom themefrom €9,000Design rounds, number of templates
Migration to Shopify from another platformfrom €5,000Data volume, URL count, integrations; a custom design is priced on top
Custom Shopify appfrom €3,000Admin screens, APIs used, checkout or Functions logic
ERP or POS integrationfrom €2,500Data flows (orders, stock, prices, customers) and how often they sync
Headless storefront (Hydrogen), standard scope€10,000–20,000Larger headless projects are quoted
Support and ongoing developmentfrom €500 a monthPlans of about 8, 20 or 45 development hours a month (€500, €1,200, €2,500)
Store audit: speed, conversion and AI search€490Credited in full against a project booked within 60 days
Shopify Plus buildsquoted per projectSystems, integrations, stores and markets, B2B rules

The licence is a separate cost that Shopify bills you directly. We break it down, with the sales level where Plus beats Advanced, in Shopify Plus Pricing 2026.

Why two quotes for the same project differ

Quotes differ because agencies assume different scopes, not because one agency is cheaper. Before comparing, send every agency the same short brief and ask them to price it line by line:

  • the platform you are leaving and the number of products, customers and orders to move;
  • every system Shopify must talk to (ERP, POS, 3PL, PIM, reviews, subscriptions);
  • custom checkout or discount logic, and any B2B price lists or payment terms;
  • the number of stores, markets and languages;
  • whether you have a design or need one.

A quote that skips one of these lines has not priced it, and it will come back as a change request.

Can you migrate to Shopify Plus for under $20,000?

Often, if the scope is a data migration onto a theme without heavy custom features and with one or two integrations. A custom design, several integrations or B2B rules push it up. With us, a migration starts at €5,000 and each ERP or POS integration at €2,500, with a custom design priced on top. Ask any agency for the same breakdown before you compare totals.

What do Shopify partner tiers mean?

A partner tier tells you how much business a partner brings to Shopify and what size of merchant usually hires it, not how good the work is. The directory shows four tiers today, Select, Plus, Premier and Platinum, and on 1 January 2027 Shopify replaces them with Silver, Gold, Platinum and Diamond.

Shopify describes today’s tiers on its hiring help page and on the tier pages of the directory:

Tier (until 31 December 2026)How Shopify describes itTypically chosen by
SelectConsistently brings new businesses to Shopify and supports their early successSmall and medium-sized businesses
PlusSupports merchant growth across more complex business needsMid-market and larger businesses
PremierDelivers sustained impact for merchants with larger, more complex businessesLarge enterprises
PlatinumSupports enterprise merchants at scale across complex operationsGlobal enterprise businesses

Every partner starts on the Registered tier, which has no badge. From 2027, Shopify’s tier rules are published as numbers. A partner needs both the attributed sales (GMV) and the number of attributed shops:

Tier (from 1 January 2027)Attributed GMVAttributed shopsMeasured over
Silver$25K11 year
Gold$5M54 years
Platinum$50M204 years
Diamond$500M254 years

Three things follow for a merchant:

  • “Platinum” changes meaning. A Platinum badge in 2027 is measured against the new bar of $50M and 20 shops, so don’t compare it with a 2026 Platinum listing.
  • Tiers lag. From 2027 a partner keeps a new tier for at least six months, even if it falls below the requirements.
  • Only Silver and above are eligible for the directory from 2027. A Registered partner can still be good, but you can’t check it there.

As of November 2026, Codersy is listed in the Plus tier.

How do you check an agency in the Partner Directory?

Search the agency’s name in the Shopify Partner Directory and compare its profile with what the agency told you. The profile mixes what the partner writes with data from Shopify, and the Shopify data is the part to trust.

  1. Tier badge. It sits next to the name. If the agency’s website claims a higher tier, ask why.
  2. Experience, based on the last 4 years of Shopify data. Top markets, top industries and top services come from Shopify, not from the agency. An agency selling you a migration should have platform migration in that list.
  3. Featured clients. They are marked “Relationships verified by Shopify”. Ask which of them you can call.
  4. Partner since, team size and active projects. These are estimates from Shopify. A team of five with 25+ active projects will stretch.

Reviews are the gap. The directory’s profile pages were redesigned in November 2026, and none of the profiles we checked on 18 November 2026 show ratings or reviews, from Plus to Platinum. Treat star ratings on an agency’s own site as unverifiable there, and make two reference calls instead.

That includes ours. Our clients left their reviews on the Partner Directory, and we copy them word for word on our reviews page (5.0 across 26 reviews), but you can no longer check them there, so ask us for a reference call too.

When the agency needs access to your store, give it through a collaborator account, never a shared login. You choose the permissions, collaborators don’t count against your staff limit, and access expires on its own after 90 days without a login.

10 questions to ask a Shopify Plus agency

Ask these on the first call and ask for the answers in the proposal. A good agency answers each one in a sentence and puts it in writing.

  1. Who owns the code, the theme and the repositories when we part ways? The answer you want: the code written for you is yours under the contract, the theme sits in a GitHub repository in your organization (Shopify’s GitHub integration connects a branch to a theme), paid themes and apps are licensed to your store, and anything the agency keeps, such as its own libraries, is listed with your right to use it.
  2. Who will write the code, and are they on your staff? Ask for names and roles, and whether any part goes to subcontractors.
  3. How do you stage and test before launch? On Plus, staging stores don’t count towards the ten-store limit, so there is no reason to build on the live store. Ask what gets tested (test orders, payments, taxes, emails, apps) and who signs off.
  4. What have you built with checkout extensibility? checkout.liquid no longer works for the information, shipping and payment steps, and was sunset for the Thank you and Order status pages on 28 August 2025. Ask to see a live checkout they customized with extensions.
  5. How will you rebuild our Shopify Scripts logic? Shopify retired Scripts on 30 June 2026, and they no longer run on any store. Discount, shipping and payment logic now runs on Shopify Functions, and only Plus stores can use custom apps that contain them.
  6. How do you map redirects? You want a sheet with every old product, collection, page and blog URL next to its new one, imported into Shopify and tested after launch. Shopify redirects fire only on URLs that return a 404, and a store can hold up to 100,000 of them (Plus stores more), per Shopify’s help page.
  7. How do you check that the data arrived? Product, customer and order counts should be reconciled before and after the move, with sample orders checked by hand. Our data migration testing checklist lists what to compare.
  8. What happens after launch, and on what terms? Ask for hours per month, reply times and the price in the contract, not “we’ll be around”.
  9. How do you price changes to the scope? Ask for the change-request process and the rate it uses, before you need it.
  10. Which Plus stores like ours can we open, and which client can we call? Open the stores, place an item in the cart, and go as far as the checkout on your phone.

Red flags when hiring a Shopify Plus agency

Walk away, or at least push back, when a proposal shows any of these:

  • It still scopes Shopify Scripts or checkout.liquid work.
  • It has a fixed price for a migration, but nobody has asked about your data, URLs or integrations.
  • It has no redirect map in the migration scope.
  • The agency asks for your owner login instead of sending a collaborator request.
  • The code and theme live in the agency’s accounts, and the contract has no handover clause.
  • The build happens on your live store, with no staging store.
  • Nobody can tell you who will write the code.
  • Support after launch is “as needed”, with no hours or reply times.
  • The tier on the agency’s site doesn’t match the Partner Directory, or the case studies name stores you can’t open.
  • It guarantees revenue or rankings.

A scoring checklist for comparing agencies

Score each agency from 0 to 5 on every line, multiply by the weight and divide by 5. The total is out of 100. Compare the top two on reference calls, not on price alone.

CriterionWeightWhat earns a 5
Plus work like yours that you can open20Two or more live Plus stores in your model (DTC, B2B, multi-market) and a client you can call
Checkout and Functions depth15Shows a live checkout built with extensions and logic built on Functions
Migration method15Written redirect map, data reconciliation and a staging store in the scope
Price you can read15Every line of your brief priced, with a written change-request process
Named team10Names and roles of the people who will build it, in-house
Ownership of code and accounts10Code, repository, theme and app licences in your name, written into the contract
Support after launch10Hours, reply times and price in writing
Directory profile matches the pitch5Tier, services and featured clients match what the agency claims

Where Codersy fits

We are a Plus-tier team that builds and migrates Plus stores with fixed prices. For examples you can open: a Shopify Plus migration with a headless rebuild and a B2B portal for Carl Friedrik across 10+ markets, a checkout extensibility app on Plus for Manukora, and a theme migration on Plus with a zero-downtime relaunch for Lox And Chain. If you run a global enterprise with many brands and teams, Shopify says that kind of business typically chooses a Premier or Platinum partner, and that is a fair place to start.

FAQ

How much does a Shopify Plus agency cost?

It depends on the project type, and most agencies quote it rather than publish it. Our published prices start at €3,000 for a store build, €5,000 for a migration, €8,000 for a custom theme and €500 a month for support; Plus builds are quoted per project. The Shopify licence is billed separately.

What is the difference between a Shopify Plus partner and a regular Shopify partner?

Plus is one of the partner tiers in Shopify’s directory. Shopify describes Plus partners as typically chosen by mid-market and larger businesses, and Select partners by small and medium-sized ones. Any partner can work on a Plus store; the tier reflects the partner’s experience and the size of merchants it usually works with.

Do Shopify partner tiers change in 2027?

Yes. On 1 January 2027 the Select, Plus and Premier tiers retire, and partners are ranked as Silver, Gold, Platinum or Diamond, based on attributed GMV and the number of attributed shops. Gold, for example, needs $5M and 5 shops over 4 years.

Should I hire a freelancer or an agency for Shopify Plus?

A freelancer suits a defined piece of work, such as a theme section or one Function. A migration, several integrations or a launch date you can’t move need a team, so one person can test while another builds and the project doesn’t stop when one person is away.

How do I check a Shopify Plus agency’s reviews?

Not in the Partner Directory: none of the profiles we checked on 18 November 2026 show ratings or reviews. Use what Shopify does verify, the tier, the services from the last 4 years of data and the featured clients, then call two of those clients.

What should I ask a Shopify Plus agency before signing?

Who owns the code and the repository, who writes it, how they stage and test, how they handle checkout extensibility and Functions, how they map redirects, and what support costs after launch. Ask for each answer in the proposal.

If you are comparing agencies for a Plus build or migration, send us your brief through our contact page and we will price it line by line, or read more about our Shopify Plus development work first.

Scaling on Shopify Plus?

Migration, B2B, architecture, performance — we run the engagements other agencies hand back.

The checklist we run before touching a client's code

Get it by email, plus a few short notes over the next two weeks: what we see most often on Shopify stores and what actually fixes it.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy

Want more of our posts in your Google results? Add Codersy as a preferred source.

Add Codersy on Google(opens in a new tab)